Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Silent Specialist

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Jasvirk
    replied
    Originally posted by Henri View Post
    Hey Nick,

    How to subscribe to try this "Smart Traders new project"?

    Thanks,
    Henri
    Hi All.

    I don't think there is any good trader over here which can give you consistent profit. I tried three traders (signals), Forex Junkie, Silent Specialist and Trade Alerter in last 4 weeks. I have lost $4,000 because of these traders. Nick recommended Trade Alerter after SS gave a big loss. I have now disabled all these 3 signals and only using one real Auto EA, which is not dependent on any human being. This auto EA made me $925 in last 6 weeks whereas these real human traders gave me loss of $4,000.

    I would again request Nick that he should enroll very highly experienced traders who can give consistent profit and you may charge even three times the current subscription but don't enroll all those who are affecting your reputation. If you continue with these type of traders then you will have to keep searching for new clients all the time and sooner the website will be known as a losers or scammers website. Make it the world's best signal provider site or just become copier service provider to traders instead of signal provider.

    My views are 100% based on my real experience using this service trading my real money. No demo account. I feel that it is my duty to inform everyone about this service and traders over here.

    Thx

    Jas

    Leave a comment:


  • Henri
    replied
    Originally posted by Nick View Post
    If you still want to gamble with a small account keep your eyes on Smart Traders new project.
    http://www.myfxbook.com/members/vijayinvites/ss/725812
    Hey Nick,

    How to subscribe to try this "Smart Traders new project"?

    Thanks,
    Henri

    Leave a comment:


  • Noesis28
    replied
    It 's true. I appreciated the fact that he have ended the trades with approximately 33% of loss and not 50%. Do not say that it is not a professional, if you say it, it's because you have not followed carefully to his trade. When he enters, the title then rises when it closes the title then goes for a few more pips and then back down. I do not know how this he do but he enters in a precise way. Compliments.

    Leave a comment:


  • richardlivefrex
    replied
    I still think Dmitry is good trader comparing with others on this board. He concentrated on one pair for trading which is not bad . The major issue about his trade is the lot size and exit strategy. The DD was too big because too many lots piled up and so he was unable to keep it running until the reverse arrived eventually. He has a big problem in exit strategy which resulted in his failure for this time and last time. Both time after the big DD occurred, he got great chance to close the orders with small profits when price down temporally. He missed it in a hope for reverse to come soon. We can't ensure when reverse point will arrive, but we should ensure the discipline is always taken properly. I didn't suffer the loss with his signal for this time ( small loss last time for his trading on USA/CAD) as I managed my account in the way with the discipline always in mind. When the big DD occurred, the first priority should be taken for breakeven or even accept with small loss. It is not wise to stick with the profit target with the big risk already in place. Otherwise , even if you were luck to win this time , you won't prevent from big loss in the future. So don't be too much complicated, Dmitry can still do his good job as long as his trading principle is improved in the way as every one noticed already.
    Last edited by richardlivefrex; 11-08-2013, 08:44 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • beaumz
    replied
    Originally posted by recint View Post
    nicely done.....wish i had done the same. I agree that SS is a good trader. He needs to shake it off and get back in there...with caution.
    Agreed on that. I want him to continue trading asap, i knew the risk before following. From the sounds of it people using money they should not be trading with. Follow this signal with max 500 bucks 0.01 size. Could wipe or 10 bag. If he does multiply the account in the future i will flip it straight into my account following viper. Always concentrate on the capital you have AT RISK

    Leave a comment:


  • Jasvirk
    replied
    Originally posted by dupapa View Post
    i like your style, good call today on the 50%
    Hi All,

    I think this can be done only if you are watching your trades all the time. Are you subscribing and paying for that? Good luck to you all and I am sure, you will soon quit this trader as he is not a professional and experienced trader but trading as if he is gambling in casino. I have disabled this trader though my $20 subscription is still live till Jan 9 but who is going to give me money to lose till Jan 9.

    I have disabled 3 traders today after losing more than $4,000 in last 4 weeks.

    Good Luck

    Jas

    Leave a comment:


  • dupapa
    replied
    Originally posted by sergiensergien View Post
    The way to do it is very easy ... I just disconected the SimpleCopier EA and adjusted the TP manually. Then I activated another EA to control DD maximum level. I did that because I wanted to be directly in control of the DD decision.

    B&KR.
    S
    i like your style, good call today on the 50%

    Leave a comment:


  • sergiensergien
    replied
    Originally posted by pearcey2 View Post
    I didn't realise there was a way to do this!

    Nick, is there any chance, when new signal providers come online, that we tell them they're still running a demo account?
    The way to do it is very easy ... I just disconected the SimpleCopier EA and adjusted the TP manually. Then I activated another EA to control DD maximum level. I did that because I wanted to be directly in control of the DD decision.

    B&KR.
    S

    Leave a comment:


  • alex_kad
    replied
    Same here!
    Originally posted by dupapa View Post
    I wouldn't of minded, I tried to exit market @ 158.25 then IC Markets platform froze from 12:45GMT for a whole 12 minutes until price had risen sharply again.

    Thanks IC Markets.

    on the note of SS, its sad to see yet another big hit on equity, 40% down again

    Leave a comment:


  • pearcey2
    replied
    Originally posted by sergiensergien View Post
    Hi, Silent and everybody

    I dediced to follow estrictly the rules of this signal and I didn't cut the trades at 40% drawdown but wait for the full 50%.

    Result? It didn't reach the 50% DD ...

    Finally GBPJPY has dropped down sharply and I went out at 22:08 GMT+1 with a price of 157.474 and a 20% win ...

    I don't think he has lost his mojo ... so I will continue following this signal.

    My best wishes to Silent Specialist.
    I didn't realise there was a way to do this!

    Nick, is there any chance, when new signal providers come online, that we tell them they're still running a demo account?

    Leave a comment:


  • recint
    replied
    Originally posted by sergiensergien View Post
    Hi, Silent and everybody

    I dediced to follow estrictly the rules of this signal and I didn't cut the trades at 40% drawdown but wait for the full 50%.

    Result? It didn't reach the 50% DD ...

    nicely done.....wish i had done the same. I agree that SS is a good trader. He needs to shake it off and get back in there...with caution.

    Finally GBPJPY has dropped down sharply and I went out at 22:08 GMT+1 with a price of 157.474 and a 20% win ...

    I don't think he has lost his mojo ... so I will continue following this signal.

    My best wishes to Silent Specialist.

    nicely done.....wish i had done the same. I agree that SS is a good trader. He needs to shake it off and get back in there...with caution.

    Leave a comment:


  • sergiensergien
    replied
    Hi, Silent and everybody

    I dediced to follow estrictly the rules of this signal and I didn't cut the trades at 40% drawdown but wait for the full 50%.

    Result? It didn't reach the 50% DD ...

    Finally GBPJPY has dropped down sharply and I went out at 22:08 GMT+1 with a price of 157.474 and a 20% win ...

    I don't think he has lost his mojo ... so I will continue following this signal.

    My best wishes to Silent Specialist.

    Leave a comment:


  • Noesis28
    replied
    Hello Silent. Silent sin for that tip 159 that made you decide to sell! Had he not done that bit now we earned a lot of money but does not do anything, I know that you are a great trader because "you can lose something that you have but not something you are. "Congratulations to the tenacity that unfortunately was not enough for little. However, today's okay!
    Forget all the negative comments. You have a good eye. Let's get straight to the target. Good evening Silent.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Damn...

    I woke up this morning and the first thing I did was check the GPBJPY. I though we'd got out of jail with a win! But then I checked the account to see that we were excited from the trade right at the peak....

    Dmitri (AKA SS) is offline at the moment so I don't have any news for you from him. As soon as I do I'll post it here.

    SS seems to have lost his groove. I speculate that it's because of the added pressure associated with having so much responsibility and promise of income from followers. It seems a strange coincidence that as soon as he puts measures in place to make money through signals that he starts losing. When you're giving something away for free or only trading for yourself it's easy not to care so much about others opinions of you, but when there is a small pot of gold 2-4 weeks away assuming you can keep generating unbelievable returns then I think it's probably hard to block that from your mind and stick to the job at hand. This is just my opinion having watched a number of traders go through this same experience after joining our site.

    Unfortunately I don't have much more to say other than I hope you were not trading this on a big account.

    If you still want to gamble with a small account keep your eyes on Smart Traders new project.

    http://www.myfxbook.com/members/vijayinvites/ss/725812

    These kind of signals are good for a bit of fun and excitement but they are not the path to real wealth trading forex. If you really want to make it then stick with a more stable trader that can show proven results over a long period of time.

    I personally love these crazy signals but I also take them for what they are.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jasvirk
    replied
    Hi Nick,

    How can we get refund for our subscription for this trader? He is failed badly and can't amend his trading habit.

    Thx.

    Jas

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X